CenterHigh
The New Zealand HeraldNews report · Sep 11, 6:48 AM
Medical centre refused doctor, defibrillator after man collapsed outside, witness claims
The man died in Auckland despite the efforts of a local business owner and passersby.
← Today's headlines
3 sources checked · 2 source groups included · 2h ago
Still Watching
Medical centre refused doctor, defibrillator after man collapsed outside, witness claims
Stuff (New Zealand) and The New Zealand Herald describe the same event in different terms.
1 Left2 Center0 Right
STILL WATCHING
As of September 11, 2026 at 7:23 AM, this is how Optics News reads the wording differences in this story.
What happened The man died in Auckland despite the efforts of a local business owner and passersby.
The headline split The left frames it as "Medical centre refused to hand over defibrillator as man died outside, witnesses say". The center frames it as "Members of public gave CPR to dying Auckland man, allege medical centre refused use of de...".
Match confidence Medium confidence. 3 sources across 2 bias buckets. Useful framing signal — check the source list before sharing.
Same-event confidenceMedium
3 sources across 2 bias buckets agree on the event.
Framing confidenceModerate
51/99 — meaningful wording shift across the spectrum.
WHAT EACH SIDE EMPHASIZED
Left / center-leftMedical centre refused to hand over defibrillator as man died outside, witnesses say
Stuff (New Zealand) · Center-left · News report
CenterMedical centre refused doctor, defibrillator after man collapsed outside, witness claims
The New Zealand Herald · Center · News report
Right / center-rightNo matching source in this bucket yet.
Optics keeps watching for pickup.
SEE THE HEADLINES
Open source
CenterHigh
Radio New ZealandNews report · Sep 11, 7:23 AM
Members of public gave CPR to dying Auckland man, allege medical centre refused use of defibrillator
A retired health worker says she spent 15 minutes giving CPR to the man on a busy Auckland street.
Center-leftMostly Factual
Stuff (New Zealand)News report · Sep 11, 7:01 AM
Medical centre refused to hand over defibrillator as man died outside, witnesses say
Bystanders say Auckland clinic staff refused a life-saving defibrillator and even a pillow for a man dying on the path outside.
Details51/99 Wording Gap · Medium confidence · 3 sources
51/99 Wording GapMedium confidence3 sources · 2 bias bucketsLive match · 3 sources · 2 buckets · comparable news formatFormats: News report
SOURCE MAP CHANGES
Sep 11, 6:48 AM: The New Zealand Herald joined the source map.
Sep 11, 7:01 AM: Stuff (New Zealand) joined the source map.
Sep 11, 7:23 AM: Radio New Zealand joined the source map.
Now: Wording Gap is 51/99 and story health is live match · 3 sources · 2 buckets · comparable news format.